Latest News Headlines
Commercial Credit News
|More public holidays would boost national wellbeing: new expert survey|
|Wednesday, 21 December 2016|
On average, people are happier during festive seasons like Christmas and New Year celebrations. What’s more, increasing the number of mandatory public holidays would improve a country’s overall wellbeing.
These are the consensus findings of a new survey from leading researchers on wellbeing from around the world. The wellbeing research group at the Centre for Economic Performance, London School of Economics is launching the World Wellbeing Panel with a ‘Christmas edition’, bringing together the views of economists, philosophers, psychologists and sociologists on the impact of public holidays on national wellbeing.
The impact of festive periods on wellbeing
The overall results are clear: 15 agree, 5 disagree and the rest have no firm opinion, implying that on balance the panel agrees with the idea that individuals are happier during the festive seasons. Yet no one strongly agrees or disagrees and several agree or abstain while acknowledging that the evidence on this issue is scarce, conflicting or unknown to them (Anna Alexandrova and Arie Kapteyn).
Some proponents – including Richard Easterlin, John Helliwell and Ruut Veenhoven – think that Christmas brings a more positive mood and temporary happiness, but not overall life satisfaction. Elizabeth Dunn notes that research on 11 European countries actually suggests that mood is lower around Christmas time, though a bit higher in the United States.
Ada Ferrer-i-Carbonell and Paul Frijters both point to US Gallup data, which show improved levels of wellbeing in the week of Christmas relative to preceding or following weeks, as measured by the ‘ladder of life’ question, which asks respondents to put themselves on a scale of the worst possible life to the best one.
On the positive side, Peter Singer expresses the consensus expectation by suggesting that Christmas sees increased social interactions, gift-giving and a break from normal routine. Such reasons are also given by Leonardo Becchetti, Daniel Benjamin, Esteban Calvo, Jan-Emmanuel De Neve, Jan Delhey, Bruno Frey, Dan Haybron, Ori Heffetz, Andrew Leigh and Ruut Veenhoven.
Mariano Calvo, Shigehiro Oishi and Heinz Welsch mention the stresses of Christmas, such as preparing food, buying gifts and having to engage in social interactions, which is not pleasant for everyone. In that regard, Nick Powdthavee refers to research showing that the number of cardiac arrests rises during Christmas, with two professors from Latin America (Mariano Rojas and Wenceslao Unanue), one from Europe (Martin Binder) and one from Canada (Chris Barrington-Leigh) noting the costs of gifts given at Christmas, which could lead to financial stress during the rest of the year or unfavourable comparisons for those too poor to keep up.
In terms of evidence, Alois Stutzer indicates that stress actually reduces in the United States around Christmas, suggesting that overall for Americans, who have far fewer holidays than people in Europe and Latin America, Christmas is a positive experience, with matters less clear elsewhere.
Andrew Clark, based in France, sums up his view on whether people have higher wellbeing at Christmas: ‘Probably most people. Stresses the hell out of me though.’
The benefits of more mandatory public holidays
Here, the results are even more pronounced, with 21 agreeing and only 2 disagreeing and with two in strong agreement (Chris Barrington-Leigh and Mariano Rojas) and only one in strong disagreement (Richard Easterlin).
What reasons do the panel give for supporting a policy of more public holidays? The main one is that people work too much in our societies and would benefit from more leisure time.
Elizabeth Dunn speaks of holidays giving us greater ‘time affluence’ and both Chris Barrington-Leigh and Paul Frijters point to the collective action problem that individuals will keep working if others keep working, implying that mandatory holidays help to break the overworking aspect of the rat-race. Similar reasons are given by Leonardo Becchetti, Esteban Calvo, Bruno Frey, Shigehiro Oishi, Mariano Rojas, Alois Stutzer and Ruut Veenhoven.
Only Heinz Welsch from Germany thinks that it would be bad in his country because they already have so many holidays there. While a few professors based in France and the United States are on the fence (Andrew Clark, Ori Heffetz, John Helliwell and Arie Kapteyn), the vast majority in the United States and Europe think that the trade-off between more leisure versus less production is worth it (Anna Alexandrova, Daniel Benjamin, Jan-Emmanuel De Neve and Ada Ferrer-i-Carbonell).
Again, the main stated evidence comes from the US Gallup survey, which, according to Ada Ferrer-i-Carbonell, shows that people are happiest during the holidays. She quotes a study by economists Alberto Alesina and colleagues in 2005, which compares people in different countries and finds higher levels of wellbeing in those with more mandatory vacations.
Forums International Ltd
Attendance at your first meeting is free of charge, and please quote reference 'CCR2016' to receive the special 10% discount off of your first annual subscription.
Find out more here.
The latest edition of CCR Magazine, the leading editorial publication in the UK credit industry, is out.
CCR is the premier magazine for consumer and credit professionals. It provides an independent voice to the industry, breaking major news stories and running in-depth features.
As a magazine, it works with and campaigns on behalf of the credit industry to promote its importance as a centre of potential profit and business development to the wider business world.
Providing information and analysis for thousands of senior credit professionals worldwide, every quarter.
GTS Media Ltd
81 Cambridge Road
Registered in England No: 05483197